Which just takes me back to my grandpappy's old, simple adage.
Son, it all depends on your perspective.
Anyways, this whole AirAmerica story is turning out to be very interesting (now that I've had some time to read more about it).
I'll give you a lengthy post here but only b/c these articles are on one of those subscription/register sites. Sorry if they bore the ADHD among us.
---------------------------------------
Statement Regarding WNTD in Chicago and KBLA in Los Angeles
Statement of Evan Cohen, Chairman of Air America Radio:
"Air America Radio is temporarily unable to be heard on WNTD in Chicago and KBLA in Los Angeles, but Chicago and Los Angeles listeners can still hear our broadcast on the web at airamericaradio.com and on XM Satellite Radio (channel 167).
"MultiCultural Radio Broadcasting's conduct in this matter has been disgraceful. To shut off a broadcast that listeners rely on without warning and in the middle of discussions is the height of irresponsibility and a slap in the face of the media industry. In addition, it is a clear violation of their contractual obligations, and we are seeking legal remedies against them in court."
Talk radio for liberals silenced in Chicago, L.A.
By John Cook, Tribune staff reporter. Tribune staff reporter Jim Kirk contributed to this report
Published April 15, 2004
After just two weeks of broadcasting, Air America Radio, the fledgling liberal talk-radio network featuring Al Franken and Janeane Garofalo, was pulled off the air Wednesday morning in Chicago and Los Angeles in a payment dispute that shows no sign of quick resolution.
Arthur Liu, owner of Multicultural Radio Broadcasting Inc., which owns Air America affiliates WNTD-950 AM in Chicago and KBLA-1580 AM in Los Angeles, said Air America bounced a check and owes him more than $1 million. Air America and Multicultural had entered into an agreement in which the network essentially was renting Multicultural's airtime, Liu said.
"They bounced a check today," Liu said. "It's a default. They have paid only a very small portion of what they owe us."
Liu declined to say how much Multicultural is owed but did say he is holding $1 million in checks that Air America has asked the company not to cash.
Air America Chairman Evan Cohen called the allegations an "outright lie."
"Multicultural Radio Broadcasting's conduct in this matter has been disgraceful," Cohen said. "[It] is a clear violation of their contractual obligations."
The dispute leaves Air America, a start-up network in a business that favors right-wing personalities and is dominated by giant conglomerates, in a tenuous position. It airs in 13 markets nationwide, and Chicago's and Los Angeles' nearly 18 million combined listeners constitute 37 percent of Air America's potential audience.
Los Angeles and Chicago, the second- and third-largest markets in the country, typically are regarded as essential when trying to sell national radio advertising. If the dispute becomes mired in court actions, it is unclear when Air America might reappear in the two markets.
Air America filed a complaint Wednesday in New York State Supreme Court charging Multicultural with breaching its contract and seeking an injunction to put Air America back on the Chicago station. An Air America source said a separate lawsuit over the Los Angeles station is coming.
The network also used its radio stations in New York, Minneapolis, Portland, Ore., and elsewhere as platforms to attack Liu. Executive vice president and general counsel David Goodfriend appeared on Air America's "The Randi Rhodes Show" to accuse Liu of essentially stealing from Air America by reselling airtime on KBLA to third parties that the network already had purchased.
Goodfriend said the dispute centers on the Los Angeles station during the period after Air America started leasing airtime in early February but before it launched in late March. During that time, he said, KBLA was broadcasting Spanish-language programming provided by Multicultural.
Goodfriend said he learned last week that Liu and Multicultural had been "double-dipping," selling that same airtime to others. As a result, he said, the network declined to make payments for KBLA unless Multicultural credited Air America for the extra money Multicultural made. Air America did not bounce any checks, he said.
"They sent us an e-mail asking us to immediately restore it and go back to the negotiating table," Liu said. "But there's nothing to negotiate. They owe us the money."
Liu did not return follow-up calls seeking a response to Air America's allegations.
Media observers say the dispute comes at a crucial time for the start-up network.
"This certainly does not help a fledgling station or network," said Paula Hambrick, who owns media-buying firm Hambrick & Associates in Orland Park. "The president had a press conference last night, so you assume that a lot of people would have wanted to hear what Al Franken had to say. This is when they are really trying to garner an audience."
Chicago-area listeners who tuned into WNTD-950 Wednesday heard Spanish-language talk radio instead of "Morning Sedition" and "Unfiltered," the network's morning talk-shows.
According to Air America's suit, a Multicultural representative showed up at WNTD's offices early Wednesday, kicked out Air America's lone staffer overseeing the network's feed to the station from New York and changed the locks on the doors.
Air America restored in Chicago
Tribune staff reporter
Published April 16, 2004
In a rapid reversal of fortunes, Air America Radio won a temporary restraining order Thursday requiring the owner of its Chicago affiliate to restore the fledgling, liberal talk-radio network's broadcast, one day after it was thrown off the air in Chicago and Los Angeles.
"We've just won Round 1," said Evan Cohen, Air America's chairman. "Arthur Liu received a clear message: Temper tantrums are not the way to conduct business."
Cohen said the network expects to resume broadcasting Friday on WNTD-950 AM in Chicago.
Liu, whose Multicultural Radio Broadcasting Inc. owns Air America's Chicago and Los Angeles stations, pulled the network off the air in both markets Wednesday and changed the locks on the doors. He told the Chicago Tribune that Air America had bounced a payment check and owed Multicultural more than $1 million.
But New York state Supreme Court Judge Marylin G. Diamond found Thursday that Air America had fully paid for airtime in Chicago and ordered Multicultural to begin broadcasting Air America's programming again.
Air America remains off the air in Los Angeles, where it had been broadcast on Multicultural's KBLA 1580 AM.
A person answering the phone Thursday at Multicultural said the company had no comment.
The dispute between the two companies began Wednesday morning, when Multicultural employees kicked Air America staffers out of the Chicago and Los Angeles stations and began airing Spanish-language programming. Liu claimed Air America had defaulted on payments for airtime.
But Air America executives said they were withholding payments for the Los Angeles station because Liu had been "double-dipping," or reselling airtime that the network had bought and paid for, prior to the network's launch a little more than two weeks ago.
Cohen said Thursday that Air America is considering its legal options regarding the Los Angeles station and would be "doing something within the next 48 hours."
Diamond scheduled a hearing on Monday to get a response from Multicultural.
No matter how the dispute is resolved, it seems unlikely that Air America will continue to broadcast on Multicultural's stations. The public relations battle became personal very quickly on Wednesday, with Liu accusing the network of insolvency, and Cohen calling Liu "disgraceful and unprofessional."
"Is this a relationship we want to continue?" Cohen asked. "Over the next couple of days we're both going to be doing a lot of thinking."
Cohen said he is "exploring other broadcast options with a partner who is more responsible and mature."
|