<a href="http://www.madison.com/captimes/sports/uw/basketball/men/mbb_recruit/32157.php" target="_blank">http://www.madison.com/captimes/sports/uw/basketball/men/mbb_recruit/32157.php</a>
-------------------------------------------
The Big Catch: Dominating Butch looks for right fit (Last in 3 part series)
By Rob Schultz
September 13, 2002
APPLETON - Richie Davis already knows how Brian Butch looks dominating a basketball game in the Dean Smith Center.
Last May, at a Tournament of Champions Invitational game played on the North Carolina home court, Butch scored 33 points, including the final six of the game, to lead his Fox Valley Skillz AAU team to victory.
The 6-foot-11 sharpshooter from Appleton outplayed Jackie Butler, a 6-9 center from McComb, Miss., who already has committed to Mississippi State. Butler scored just 12 points and had 8 rebounds before fouling out.
Butch then scored 36 points while outplaying another top-rated center, 6-10 Darryl Watkins of Patterson, N.J., as the Skillz lost to Milwaukee Bucks forward Tim Thomas' AAU team made up of select East Coast prep all-stars at Cameron Indoor Stadium on the Duke campus. Watkins finished with 9 points before fouling out.
Finally, Butch returned to the Dean Smith Center and scored 25 points and grabbed 16 rebounds as the Skillz defeated an AAU team from Massachusetts led by 6-10 Hassan Fofana, who finished with 13 points.
By the time he left North Carolina, Butch was offered a scholarship from the Tar Heels and was a media celebrity. Within a few weeks, he jumped up the charts of every national recruiting list in the country.
"I've never seen such a swarm of people come in to watch a kid play," said Davis, the Fox Valley Skillz coach. "It looked like an NBA playoff game with all the media surrounding Brian asking him questions."
And college coaches swarmed to Davis to learn more about Butch. "Everybody wanted him," said Davis. "Florida, North Carolina State, UConn all tried to jump in."
But Butch has narrowed his list to the University of Wisconsin, Marquette, Arizona, Kansas and North Carolina.
Davis, as well as Butch's high school coach, Greg Hartjes at Appleton West, have gotten to know - and like - all the coaches involved in Butch's recruitment. They also have studied most of the pros and cons that Butch is weighing as he readies himself to make a decision.
First, they believe wherever he attends college he'll make a strong impact and will carry the program.
"There will be a lot of pressure on him," said Hartjes, "and I don't think that will bother him at all. He's a mentally tough kid."
But at what position he dominates is a subject for debate. Butch weighs just 215 pounds and he envisions playing at the 4 spot (power forward) in college, particularly after proving this summer that he can consistently make 3-pointers. Davis and Hartjes both believe he'll play the 5, or center position, as well as the 4.
The problems he may face won't be on offense. He has proven he can score on anyone. But stopping the other guy could be a problem initially, especially at the 4 spot.
Hartjes said coaches have a concern about his lateral quickness and ability to defend out on the perimeter.
For instance, "Duke has gone away from recruiting big kids. Their roster is full of 6-8 kids. They have gone away from the plodders because they want to make people match up with them," Hartjes said. "So North Carolina is saying that Brian has to go out and guard a very quick 6-8 kid. That's what they are more concerned about; more so than his bulk."
Duke isn't the only school going with quickness. As a 4, he would face similar situations in the Big 12 at Kansas, the Pac-10 at Arizona, Conference USA at Marquette and the Big Ten at Wisconsin.
But both Hartjes and Davis said the UW has an edge over the other schools because they have secured a verbal commitment for the 2004 class from Randolph center Greg Stiemsma, who is a much better defender. By the time he finishes high school, Stiemsma may end up as highly ranked nationally as Butch.
"With Stiemsma in there, that would allow Brian to match up somewhere else. That's what coaches are always looking to do," said Hartjes. "So Brian is not the best defender, you have to find somebody who is to guard the other team's best post players."
Davis had the luxury of coaching both players on the same team for a short period this summer. "In one word: awesome," said Davis.
"Anybody who says they can't play together I won't listen to them," he added. "I can honestly say that I've seen it happen and they were great together."
Butch knows UW coach Bo Ryan's swing offense is tailor-made for him because it would allow him to use his wide array of moves.
"That is really taste-worthy," he said of the offense. "I can step up and hit the long shot and then there's a one-on-one post where they can't double team. If they do, you have to kick it out for the 3. It's definitely a great system. And they won with it without having all the tools."
Butch also acknowledged the addition of Stiemsma makes playing for the Badgers even more attractive.
"He is 10 times a better defensive player than I am right now," said Butch, who played with Stiemsma in a few tournament games this summer and considers him a friend. He's a good guy. I like him a lot."
Hartjes said Butch has to look at all the potential situations at every school. "He has to look at the rosters of all these schools to see where he will fit in," Hartjes said. "I'm concerned about some of them. At Carolina I think he'll end up at the 5 spot because they signed the No. 1 power forward this year."
If Butch committed to Arizona, he'd spend his freshman year playing behind 6-10 center Channing Frye. They have even discussed the idea of redshirting Butch so he could develop more without so much pressure.
"They believe Frye will go pro after his junior year and Brian would then get 25-30 minutes a game his (redshirt) freshman year," said Hartjes.
Hartjes has had a hard time figuring out what Kansas has planned for Butch.
"We were kind of concerned about the scholarship offer at first because they were kind of vague," he said. "They didn't talk at all about him fitting in with this guy or that guy like the other schools have. Recently they've put a little bit of a push on, but I'm not sure how to read it."
Kansas also is recruiting highly regarded 6-11 David Padgett of Reno, Nev., and some believe he's leaning toward playing for the Jayhawks. But Padgett also is being recruited by Arizona and North Carolina as well as Stanford, which Butch crossed off his list earlier this summer.
"I think Kansas is higher on Padgett than they are on Brian while I think everybody else is higher on Brian," said Hartjes.
Arizona also is recruiting power forward Ndudi Ebi, another top-10 prospect from Houston.
"So if they get one of the three, they'll be happy," said Hartjes. "North Carolina loves Brian, but if they get Padgett they'll be pretty darned happy. Now Wisconsin has only offered to Brian. They have put all their eggs in one basket to get the kid. They have to do it that way."
There lies the major difference between perennial powerhouses and schools like Wisconsin trying to scratch their way to the top.
Hartjes said the UW coaches are impatient waiting for Butch to make a decision because they have so much on the line. Meantime, the other schools look more polished because they are more patient after going through so many recruiting battles and have the power to make contingency plans.
Even Marquette coach Tom Crean has been more patient than the UW staff. But that's because the Golden Eagles have nothing to lose with their recruitment of Butch. Hartjes said Crean knows his program is the lowest of the five schools on Butch's list.
"They were almost ready to concede that they weren't going to be the fifth school and gain a visit. And then, right at the end, Tom Crean did some smooth talking with Brian and got a visit out of it," Hartjes said.
"They are hoping they have a chance," the Appleton West coach added. "They are hoping to spark something. They are hoping that when he comes down for that visit, that he says this is the greatest place, this is where I want to be. But they also understand they are up against some big-time programs."
Hartjes has been most comfortable with Ryan and his staff and admitted he wants Butch to play there.
"Maybe it's because they are Midwestern people who are from Wisconsin. They understand a little bit more about Brian and Wisconsin kids," he said. "Some of the other schools, there is a lot of flash."
Ryan has even shown Hartjes a few wrinkles of his swing offense that he can implement into West's sets this season as the Terrors try to return to the WIAA boys state tournament in Madison.
"If he asks me where I think he should go, I'll say Wisconsin," said Hartjes. "But he hasn't asked me and I haven't told him."
Plus, Hartjes added, "It would also be pretty exciting to see one of my players run out on the court with a North Carolina uniform on, too. Or Arizona. That's the thing that Brian sees, whether he has a better opportunity at those schools."
Hartjes and Davis, as well as Butch's father, Pete, believe the star player's love for his family and their desire to see him play close to home may play a role in his decision.
"I mentioned that to Brian two or three times," said Pete Butch. "He knows it means a lot to have your friends and family there."
But, like Hartjes and Davis, Pete Butch will let his son make his own decision.
"Brian knows that he has to do what is best for himself and where he best fits into their style of play," he said.
<small>[ September 13, 2002, 04:41 PM: Message edited by: hoops13 ]</small>
|