(04-18-2011 09:36 AM)WacoBearcat Wrote: Hopefully, numbers will be run for various scenarios (split, stay, 10/17, 12/20 etc).
The current TV deal is about 2/3 for basketball and 1/3 for football.
If you take the high number quoted ($130 million per year), apply the current distribution and assume for the time being that Villanova doesn't move up, it would have the following averages:
Basketball - $87 million per year average; $5.12 million per basketball school
Football - $43 million per year average; $4.78 million per football school
So, at $130 million per year, the schools that play both football and basketball would make just a tad under $10 million per year on average.
Assume that the football number is a constant (that number isn't going to change whether or not you split). That means that if there's a split, a 9-team all-sports conference would need to pull in about $46 million for basketball in order to break even. Note that no one is going to split just to break even - there has to be a substantial benefit for making that move. You likely need to get around $8 million per year per school for basketball ($72 million per year for 9 schools) in order to make it worth it. Are the 8 Catholic schools only worth $15 million (the difference between what would make a split league worth it versus what's on the table for a hybrid) all put together?
Here's where the dichotomy lies. For a lot of split proponents, they believe that if "all things are equal", then that supports a split. In reality, it's exactly the opposite for the university presidents - for them, if "all things are equal", then there's absolutely zero reason to make a move and incur a massive amount of litigation costs. It has to be a whole lot more compelling financial change in order to justify a split and there's clearly doubts as to whether the UCF/Houston-types would really add enough (if anything at all).
Think of it this way: under these figures, each additional Big East school has to bring in $10 million each just to break even, meaning that those expansion candidates actually have to bring in $12 million each or so to make a really good case. Is UCF really going to add $12 million per year? Is Houston? Heck, would even Missouri or Kansas do that? These are the benchmarks that people need to starting taking into account.