(10-31-2018 09:31 AM)johnintx Wrote: After checking it out, I see that the OSU team that went to the 2015 Sugar Bowl was ranked 16th. They are the lowest ranked P5 team to make a New Year's Six game in the CFP era. Auburn was ranked 14th in 2016 when they filled the SEC spot in the Sugar Bowl. The Sugar Bowl is tied to the SEC and Big 12, regardless of ranking, except in years when they host a CFP semifinal.
There's zero doubt that in a year like this one where the Sugar Bowl is not a playoff bowl, and if the Big 12 champ does make the playoffs, there WILL be a Big 12 team in the Sugar Bowl. That's a fact, that's the nature of the contract. Doesn't matter if the next-best Big 12 team is ranked #6 or #20 or is unranked - the Big 12 will send a team to the Sugar Bowl this year.
BUT, Hokie's question asks about the
process used to select that Big 12 Sugar Bowl team if the champ is in the playoffs. And that's a good question, because the Big 12 has had a different procedure: Whereas the ACC and SEC just go by the straight CFP rankings to place their non-champ in the Orange and Sugar bowls, the Big 12 has NOT gone by the CFP rankings but rather has used their own internal tie-breaker to decide it.
That's why, in 2015, #16 Oklahoma State went to the Sugar Bowl while #11 TCU played in the Alamo Bowl - even though the CFP had TCU five spots higher, OK State was the #2 Big 12 team according to the Big 12's own tie-breaker process.
BUT #2, the last time that procedure was tested was in 2015, and at that time, the Big 12 did not have a CCG. Now, it does, which raises the issue of whether with the advent of the CCG, the Big 12 has changed its policy. If it hasn't, then that would mean that unlike the SEC, the Big 12 CCG runner-up WOULD automatically go to the Sugar Bowl as the Big 12 rep (assuming the runner-up doesn't make the playoffs of course as a second Big 12 team) even if there was another Big 12 team that wasn't the champ and not in the playoffs that is ranked ahead of them (like TCU vs OK State in 2015).
But #3, maybe the Big 12 has changed its policy and now goes by straight CFP rankings like the SEC. I don't know.