(10-06-2022 07:10 PM)Bull Wrote: (10-06-2022 04:26 PM)Fishpro10987 Wrote: Every league is already too big.
We need 10 team regional conferences.
Sorry, and old-timer venting here.
You are absolutely right...
A 20-24 team monstrosity is just two conferences stuck together anyway... IDC what they call it...
Maybe someday it will cycle around again and we'll see 'split' of some of these...
I think that is a real possibility. IMO, once you get to 16 schools, like the B1G and SEC will be at, you theoretically have two eight-school football conferences gestating inside you. Over time, these two might decide to hive-off from each other.
Taking the SEC as a case: That is one reason why I believed the SEC should not expand beyond 14 schools. Now, I know that you can't turn down Texas and Oklahoma, but nevertheless, there is that danger.
Also, IMO the SEC would be wise to not add any more Big 12 schools in the future, because if you add schools from a particular region, they are IMO more likely to be a hive-off threat down the road. E.g., I could see a scenario after which "using" the SEC to regain strength, the old Big 12 schools - Missouri, Arkansas, Texas, Oklahoma, and TAMU - decide they are too culturally dissimilar with the "southeast" schools and hive-off.
In that regard, I think the B1G is safer, as its expansion targets over the past 10-12 years - Rutgers, MD, UNL, USC and UCLA - are more scattered, there is no critical mass from a particular region that could form a hive-off nucleus.
Once a conference gets that big, I would also avoid creating (or keeping) divisions, especially based on geography, as these divisions are in effect two separate conferences-in-waiting. Better to abandon divisions and mix up the schedules among all the members. Again, the SEC seems more vulnerable to that IMO than the B1G.
That's a lot of verbiage-spill to say I agree with you, and really, think the threat of splits and hive-offs is present even before we reach the 20- or 24- team thresholds. I think the B1G and SEC are already at that point.
Of course, these hive-offs would not necessarily be a bad thing, they are only bad if one thinks the whole big gang of a conference should stay together, and individual schools or configurations may not believe this is in their interest.